When Square Loyalty wins
Square Loyalty is the cleaner operational choice when a merchant already runs its sales, customer directory and online ordering through Square and wants loyalty activity recorded automatically inside that ecosystem.
Comparison
Digital Loyalty vs Square Loyalty
Square Loyalty is deeply integrated with Square POS and Square Online; Digital Loyalty is wallet-native and can operate independently of the payment system.
The honest take
When Digital Loyalty wins
Digital Loyalty is the stronger fit when the loyalty card itself must work in both Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, the business wants to avoid committing loyalty to one POS, or a flexible POS/CRM integration is needed.
Feature-by-feature
| Feature | Digital Loyalty | Square Loyalty |
|---|---|---|
| Customer wallet delivery Square’s current UK product page documents an Apple Wallet digital loyalty pass. | Apple Wallet + Google Wallet | Apple Wallet loyalty pass |
| Core earning mechanics | Stamps or points | Points by visits, spend, items or categories |
| Checkout workflow Any Digital Loyalty connection is scoped against the existing Square workflow. | Staff scan or agreed integrated workflow | Native Square POS / Online workflow |
| Customer enrolment | QR journey into the phone wallet | Square POS, Square Online, Invoices or signup link |
| Customer messages | Wallet pass updates and notifications | Transactional SMS and loyalty promotions |
| Multi-location operation | ✓ | ✓ |
| Integration flexibility Square states programme setup and configuration remain in Square Dashboard. | API-enabled integration options | Square Loyalty API |
| Additional programme types | Coupons and membership cards | Multi-reward point tiers |
| Location-triggered wallet relevance | Apple/Google controlled | Not stated in reviewed sources |
Pricing
Digital Loyalty
From £29/month
Go £29, Plus £59 and Pro £99. Multi-location and bespoke integration requirements use a scoped Custom plan. Direct signup has a 30-day trial.
Full pricing →Square Loyalty
£25/month per location
UK pricing is based on loyalty visits: £25 for 0-500, £45 for 501-1,500 and £65 for 1,501+ visits per calendar month, per location. Square advertises a 30-day trial.
Square Loyalty pricing →Switching from Square Loyalty
- 1 Document the current Square earning rules, reward tiers, participating locations and customer identifiers.
- 2 Confirm which customer and loyalty fields Square will export or expose through its APIs; do not assume every balance or history field can be migrated.
- 3 Map only supported fields into Digital Loyalty through a reviewed integration or import process.
- 4 Pilot the new wallet journey with one representative location and reconcile balances before any wider communication.
- 5 Run a controlled transition and retire Square Loyalty only after staff workflow, customer support and data reconciliation pass.
Frequently asked questions
Can Digital Loyalty operate while I keep Square for payments?
Yes. Square can continue processing payments while staff scan a Digital Loyalty wallet card or use an integrated workflow agreed during discovery.
How does Square Loyalty pricing compare?
Square’s reviewed UK pricing is £25, £45 or £65 per location per month depending on monthly loyalty visits. Digital Loyalty self-serve plans are £29, £59 and £99; multi-location and integration requirements should be scoped as a Custom plan. Compare the operational workflow and required wallet platforms, not only the entry price.
Can every Square customer and point balance be migrated automatically?
That should not be promised before a data review. Export/API availability, identifiers, consent, balance mapping and history requirements must be checked, then proved in a pilot.
Does Digital Loyalty use a Square card reader?
No. Square hardware can remain the payment system, but Digital Loyalty uses its own wallet-card scanning workflow unless a bespoke API integration is implemented.
Sources and review date
Competitor facts were checked against the first-party sources below on . Prices and features can change; follow the source links before buying.
More comparisons
Ready to make the switch?
Start with a 30-day trial, or talk to us about a controlled migration and integration pilot.
Start free trial